The US Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit affirmed a jury verdict finding willful and malicious trade secret misappropriation and declined to review the denial of summary judgment after trial because it involved factual rather than purely legal issues. The Court vacated an attorneys’ fees award, however, because the district court failed to consider the plaintiff’s overall degree of success. Wilbur-Ellis Company, LLC v. Cody Downing, Case No. 25-2865 (8th Cir. Nov. 9, 2026) (Loken, Benton, Erickson, JJ.)
Cody Downing worked as a sales representative for Wilbur-Ellis before resigning to join a competitor. Before his departure, Downing copied hundreds of files containing Wilbur-Ellis’ confidential customer purchasing information, sales forecasts, budgets, strategies, orders, inventory, and pricing information. Wilbur-Ellis sued Downing for trade secret misappropriation, breach of the duty of loyalty, and tortious interference with business relations. Downing moved for summary judgment on all claims and, at trial, moved for judgment as a matter of law on the issues of damages and causation. The district court denied his summary judgment motion on the misappropriation claims and deferred ruling on his motion for judgment as a matter of law.
A jury found that Downing willfully and maliciously misappropriated Wilbur-Ellis’ trade secrets and awarded about $200,000 in damages. The district court subsequently awarded almost $450,000 in attorneys’ fees. Downing renewed his motion for judgment as a matter of law, which the lower court denied. Downing appealed the denial of his summary judgment motion on the misappropriation claims, the denial of his renewed motion, and the award of attorneys’ fees.
Post-trial review of summary judgment motion
The Eighth Circuit explained that denial of summary judgment is generally not reviewable after trial unless the motion presents a purely legal issue. The district court had found genuine disputes of material fact as to each of the four elements of Wilbur-Ellis’ misappropriation claims. Downing argued that the fixed factual record rendered the district court’s ruling purely legal. The Court disagreed, explaining that Downing’s sufficiency of the evidence arguments would require it to review the pretrial record, assess the evidence and permissible inferences, and determine whether a reasonable jury could find for Wilbur-Ellis. Because that inquiry did not present a “purely legal issue,” the Court declined to review the denial of summary judgment.
Attorneys’ fees
The Eighth Circuit vacated the award of attorneys’ fees, finding that the district court abused its discretion by failing to consider Wilbur-Ellis’ overall degree of success. Relying on the 1983 US Supreme Court decision in Hensley v. Eckerhart, the Eighth Circuit explained that although fees attributable to unsuccessful claims generally should be excluded, segregation may be impracticable when successful and unsuccessful claims arise from a common core of facts or related legal theories. The Eighth Circuit found no abuse of discretion in the district court’s decision not to segregate fees because Wilbur-Ellis’ claims were factually related. However, that determination did not relieve the district court of its separate obligation to evaluate whether the overall results obtained justified the fees awarded.
The Eighth Circuit emphasized that the degree of success obtained is the most critical factor in determining a reasonable fee award. Wilbur-Ellis sought $1.56 million in damages but recovered only about $200,000, approximately 13% of the amount requested. Although the district court reduced the requested fees based on hourly rates, billing practices, and Wilbur-Ellis’ litigation conduct, none of those adjustments addressed the substantial disparity between the damages sought and recovered. The Eighth Circuit explained that while attorneys’ fees need not be proportional to the damages recovered, the district court must consider the relationship between the relief sought and the results achieved when assessing the reasonableness of the award. Because the district court failed to address that relationship, the Eighth Circuit could not conclude that the omission was harmless and remanded the fee award for reconsideration.
Practice note: Plaintiffs pursuing trade secret litigation should carefully evaluate the damages they seek and the evidence supporting those amounts. Even when a company prevails on its misappropriation claims and establishes entitlement to attorneys’ fees, a substantial disparity between the damages sought and recovered may result in a reduced fee award.




