Mi casa no es su Casa Azul: Fifth Circuit revives tequila infringement claim

By on November 19, 2026
Posted In Trademarks

The US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit vacated a judgment of no trademark infringement, finding that the district court erred in evaluating four likelihood-of-confusion factors, including by considering third-party use of a term absent from the senior user’s mark and discounting evidence of actual consumer confusion. Casa Tradición S.A. de C.V. v. Casa Azul Spirits, L.L.C., Case No. 24-20255 (5th Cir. Nov. 4, 2026) (Elrod, Guidry, JJ.) (Engelhardt, J., concurring in part and dissenting in part).

Casa Tradición (Clase Azul) has sold luxury tequila under the CLASE AZUL mark in the United States since 2003. Its tequila is packaged in distinctive hand-painted ceramic decanters and sold at premium prices. Casa Azul Spirits (Casa Azul) owns registrations for the CASA AZUL mark covering wine and, since 2019, alcoholic beverages other than beer. Casa Azul launched canned tequila sodas in 2022 and organic, additive-free bottled tequila in 2023. Clase Azul sued for trademark infringement under the Lanham Act and Texas law. Following a bench trial, the district court found no likelihood of confusion. Clase Azul appealed.

The Fifth Circuit reviewed the district court’s findings under the eight likelihood-of-confusion factors (known in the Fifth Circuit as the “digits of confusion”) and identified errors in four of them.

Strength of the mark

The Fifth Circuit found that the district court clearly erred in finding that CLASE AZUL was descriptive rather than suggestive. Although “azul” (Spanish for “blue”) could refer to the blue Weber agave plant used to make tequila, consumers must exercise imagination to make that connection. The Court also noted that “blue class,” the English translation of CLASE AZUL, does not appear in dictionaries, competitors do not need the phrase to describe tequila, and no other tequila brand uses it.

The Fifth Circuit also rejected the district court’s finding that CLASE AZUL lacked marketplace recognition, citing more than 20 years of use, annual sales exceeding $200 million, and extensive media coverage.

Addressing third-party use, the Fifth Circuit found that the district court applied the wrong legal standard by considering third-party marks containing “casa” and “azul,” rather than focusing on “clase” and “azul,” the terms in the senior user’s mark. The Court explained that third-party use of a term absent from the senior mark cannot diminish that mark’s strength. The Court rejected Clase Azul’s argument that only marks combining “clase” and “azul” were relevant, however, because third-party use of a shared component could also bear on the mark’s strength. The Court remanded for further findings on relevant third-party use, explaining that the absence of sales or survey evidence affects the weight of such evidence, not its relevance.

Similarity of the marks and products

The Fifth Circuit found no clear error in the district court’s determination that the marks, although similar in sound, differed in appearance and meaning.

The Fifth Circuit reached a different conclusion regarding the similarity of the products. It concluded that the district court erred by focusing on differences in price and marketing, including Casa Azul’s organic, additive-free positioning, rather than whether consumers might believe the products originated from the same source. Both parties sold bottled tequila with 40% alcohol content, and the price difference was insufficient to make a common source implausible. The Court also concluded that Casa Azul’s canned tequila sodas were sufficiently related to Clase Azul’s bottled tequila because consumers could reasonably believe that a tequila producer had expanded into ready-to-drink cocktails. The relevant inquiry was consumer perception, not whether Clase Azul actually intended to enter that market.

Retail outlets and advertising

The Fifth Circuit found clear error in the district court’s conclusion that the parties served different consumers and retail outlets, noting evidence that Clase Azul products were sold in grocery and big-box stores. The Court nevertheless upheld the finding that the products generally occupied different sections or price categories within shared stores. It also upheld the finding that the parties used different advertising methods, with Clase Azul relying primarily on unpaid media exposure and Casa Azul using paid campaigns.

Actual confusion

Although Clase Azul did not challenge the district court’s findings that Casa Azul’s survey showing confusion rates below 2% was reliable and Clase Azul’s survey was not, the Fifth Circuit found that the district court failed to adequately consider anecdotal evidence of confusion. That evidence included a distributor employee and bar owner who believed Casa Azul was a new Clase Azul product, an online review of Clase Azul accompanied by a photograph of a Casa Azul bottle, and retailers mislabeling the products.

The Fifth Circuit explained that actual confusion need not involve a completed purchase and that confusion among distributors and other industry participants is relevant. Despite the survey results, the anecdotal evidence required the actual confusion factor to favor Clase Azul. The Fifth Circuit left the weight of that factor to the district court on remand.

The Fifth Circuit upheld the district court’s purchaser-care finding but concluded that errors in evaluating the strength of the mark; similarity of the products, retail outlets, and purchasers; and actual confusion undermined the overall likelihood-of-confusion determination.

Judge Engelhardt concurred in part and dissented in part, arguing that the majority improperly reweighed evidence under the clear-error standard. He emphasized differences in the parties’ products and packaging, evidence that consumers confused the names before Casa Azul entered the tequila market, and Clase Azul’s delay in challenging the CASA AZUL mark.

Jolie B. Schenerman
Jolie Schenerman is a member of McDermott Will & Schulte's Litigation Group. Read Jolie Schenerman's full bio.

STAY CONNECTED

TOPICS

ARCHIVES